When I look at horse feed, I believe it is important to consider more than simply the protein, fibre, sugar, starch, vitamins and minerals listed on the label. The nature and concentration of the plant compounds present in the ingredients also matter.
Plants naturally produce a wide range of secondary metabolites as part of their defence mechanisms and normal metabolism. These include salicylic acid, tannins, bitter compounds, biogenic amines, saponins, glucosinolates, oxalic acid, phytic acid, coumarin derivatives and cyanogenic glycosides.
These compounds occur naturally in many plants, including herbs, sainfoin, alfalfa, spices, mushrooms and algae. Their presence, however, does not automatically make a plant toxic. Their effects depend on the individual compound, its concentration, how much is consumed, how frequently it is fed, and the horse’s overall diet.
This distinction is important. I am not suggesting that every plant containing these compounds is dangerous. Horses naturally encounter many plant secondary metabolites when grazing. My concern is with deliberately concentrating or adding such compounds to a horse’s daily feed when they are not nutritionally necessary.
What are these compounds?
Many of these substances are referred to as anti-nutritional factors because, depending on their concentration, they can interfere with digestion, nutrient absorption or normal physiological processes.
Tannins, for example, can bind proteins and minerals. At moderate levels they may have some useful biological effects, but at higher concentrations they can reduce protein digestibility, mineral availability and palatability.
Phytic acid (phytate) is the principal storage form of phosphorus in many seeds and grains. It can bind minerals such as zinc, iron, calcium and magnesium, reducing their bioavailability.
Oxalic acid can bind calcium to form poorly soluble calcium oxalate. Excessive exposure can therefore reduce calcium availability and, depending on the plant and dose, contribute to calcium disturbances.
Saponins are surface-active compounds that can interact with cell membranes. At sufficiently high concentrations they may affect the gastrointestinal tract and interfere with nutrient utilisation.
Glucosinolates, found particularly in plants of the Brassica family, can break down into compounds that interfere with iodine utilisation and thyroid function when consumed in excessive amounts.
Coumarin derivatives comprise a diverse group of compounds. Certain derivatives can interfere with blood coagulation, while some breakdown products can have toxic effects at sufficiently high exposure.
Cyanogenic glycosides deserve particular attention because some can release hydrogen cyanide when plant tissue is damaged or digested. Cyanide interferes with cellular respiration and can be highly toxic at sufficient doses.
Biogenic amines, including compounds such as histamine and tyramine, are biologically active substances that can influence vascular, neurological and gastrointestinal processes. Their significance depends strongly on concentration and individual tolerance.
Salicylic acid is a naturally occurring compound related to acetylsalicylic acid (aspirin). At sufficiently high exposure, salicylates can affect the gastrointestinal tract, kidneys and blood coagulation.
Bitter compounds are a very broad category and cannot all be considered harmful. Some have recognised biological effects and may stimulate digestive processes. Others can reduce palatability or exert stronger physiological effects. Therefore, the specific compound and its concentration are important.
Natural does not automatically mean appropriate
This is where I believe there is often confusion in horse nutrition.
A substance being natural does not automatically make it beneficial or appropriate as a feed ingredient. Plants produce many compounds specifically as chemical defences against insects, herbivores and competing plants.
At the same time, the presence of a secondary compound does not automatically make a plant toxic. Dose is fundamental.
A horse consuming a diverse pasture will naturally encounter numerous plant secondary metabolites in relatively small and variable quantities. That is very different from deliberately including a concentrated plant ingredient in a formulated feed and providing it repeatedly over a long period.
For me, this distinction is fundamental.
Why I prefer not to deliberately concentrate them
My approach to horse nutrition is based on providing the nutrients a horse actually requires while keeping unnecessary physiological challenges to a minimum.
If an ingredient provides a specific nutritional benefit, then there should be a clear reason for including it. But I do not see a nutritional advantage in deliberately concentrating compounds that can potentially interfere with mineral absorption, protein utilisation, digestion or other physiological processes.
This is particularly relevant when the ingredient is fed daily and in relatively concentrated quantities.
I therefore prefer to formulate feeds around well-characterised, predictable ingredients with a clear nutritional purpose, rather than relying on a long list of botanicals simply because they are considered “natural” or are associated with a particular health claim.
What about sainfoin and alfalfa?
It is important to be precise here.
Sainfoin and alfalfa are not poisonous plants, and their presence in a horse’s environment does not automatically constitute a health risk. Sainfoin, for example, contains condensed tannins, which have been studied for their effects on protein utilisation and gastrointestinal parasites.
However, the fact that a compound can have a biological effect does not mean that it needs to be concentrated in a formulated horse feed.
I therefore distinguish between a horse naturally encountering a plant as part of a diverse forage environment and deliberately adding concentrated plant material to a daily ration.
My preference is the latter should only be done when there is a clear, evidence-based nutritional reason.
My approach to horse nutrition
Ultimately, I believe good horse nutrition should be based on what the horse needs rather than what can be added to a feed.
The foundation should remain high-quality forage, with supplementary feeds used to correct genuine nutritional requirements rather than to introduce unnecessary ingredients.
I am therefore cautious about ingredients that bring a significant load of secondary plant compounds without providing a corresponding nutritional necessity.
My guiding question is simple:
What does the horse actually need, and can I provide it in the most nutritionally appropriate and predictable way possible?
For me, that is a more scientifically sound approach than assuming that natural automatically means beneficial.


Leave a reply